The game
What is Tipping Point?
Tipping Point is a balance game: an everyday object over a fulcrum, and your job is to put the fulcrum right under the point where its weight balances.
Each round holds one object over a fulcrum: a claw hammer, a baseball bat, a wine bottle, an electric guitar. You slide it until you think the fulcrum is under its balance point, then let go, and it is set down on the fulcrum's flat top, which sharpens to a point under it. If its balance point is over the point, it holds. If not, it tips over as soon as the top's edge passes under its balance point, late when the miss is small and at once when it is large, then falls and lands. How close you were is your score.
The objects come from a catalog of 117 tools, sports and outdoor gear, instruments, kitchen and household things and food, each built from its real parts: their sizes, their materials and, where a maker publishes them, their weights. A run is 5 rounds, and every pivot is judged as a share of the object's length, so a pencil is marked exactly as a shovel is.
- rounds in a run, each weighted more than the last
- 5
- points for a perfect run
- 1,000
- of the length off the balance point, and a pivot scores nothing
- 20%
The name
What does Tipping Point mean?
A tipping point is the last place a leaning thing can be before it falls, and the game asks you to find the place furthest from it.
The phrase began as plain mechanics. Lean a box on its edge and it rocks back while its weight is over the edge it stands on; past that point it tips. The point where it goes from one to the other is its tipping point, and the phrase has since come to mean any moment when a small change tips a whole system from one state to another.
In the game the edge is the fulcrum's. Its top starts as a flat strip 40% of the object's length wide and narrows to a point 2% wide: while the balance point is over the strip the object stands, and once an edge has passed under the balance point it has passed its tipping point and goes over.
A short history
Where the science of balance comes from
Merchants, mathematicians and physicists each worked out a piece of why a thing balances where it does.
c. 2400 BC
The beam balance
The oldest known weighing scales, from the Indus Valley, hang two pans from a beam on a central pivot. A balance weighs by finding the moment when the beam holds level, the same moment the game asks you to find.
c. 250 BC
The law of the lever
Archimedes proves in On the Equilibrium of Planes that weights balance at distances in inverse proportion to their size, and finds the center of gravity of a triangle and other figures. Every balance since rests on his proof.
1586
The art of weighing
Simon Stevin publishes The Elements of the Art of Weighing, a book of statics that works out when bodies on slopes and beams hold still, and turns the center of gravity into an engineer's tool.
1687
One point stands for the whole
Isaac Newton shows in the Principia that a body's center of mass moves as if all its mass were gathered there. A falling hammer may tumble, but that one point falls in a clean arc.
1765
How things turn
Leonhard Euler sets out the motion of rigid bodies, with the moment of inertia that decides how fast a thing turns about its center of mass, the quantity that makes a long ski topple slowly and a short hammer fast.
Now
Simulated at real size
Tipping Point builds each object from its parts, finds its balance point from their masses, and simulates its fall at its real size, so every tip, roll and bounce follows the physics these four worked out.
Why it works
Why is the balance point so hard to see?
Most lost rounds are not careless. They come from judging an object by its shape when its balance is set by its weight.
The outline pulls you to the middle
The eye finds the middle of a shape easily, so a first guess drifts toward it. The balance point is the middle of the weight instead, and on anything with a heavy end the two can be a third of the length apart.
Density is invisible
Two parts the same size can weigh very different amounts. Steel is about 17 times as dense as pine, so a hammer's small steel head can outweigh a handle far longer than it, and nothing in its outline says so.
Hollow parts deceive
A guitar's body, a broom's bristles and an umbrella's canopy look heavy because they are big, and weigh little because they are mostly air. The balance point sits further from them than their size suggests.
Your hand knows, your eye does not
Holding a tool, you feel its balance as the turning effort at your wrist, a sense psychologists call dynamic touch. Looking at a picture, you have only the shape and what you know of the materials to go on.
The method
How to find the balance point in Tipping Point
Four habits that turn a hunch into a measured pivot.
01
Find the heaviest part first
Look for the densest, most solid part: metal before wood, wood before plastic, anything solid before anything hollow. The balance point always lies on its side of the middle.
02
Start beside it
Rather than starting from the middle and working out, set the fulcrum just inside the heavy part and work back toward the light end. It keeps the outline from pulling you to the center.
03
Weigh the rest as a lever
A long light part a long way out can balance a short heavy one close in, as Archimedes proved. Ask how much the light end weighs, then how far its middle is from the fulcrum, and move until the two sides feel even.
04
Watch the reveal
After each round a faint copy of the object goes back on the fulcrum with its balance point marked and the gap to your pivot measured. Compare where it sat with what you guessed, and you learn how far each kind of part moves it.
| Within 1% of the length | 100 points, balanced |
|---|---|
| 3% off | 85 points |
| 5% off | 70 points |
| 10% off | 38 points |
| 15% off | 13 points |
| 20% off or more | 0 points |
In this game
How Tipping Point turns a pivot into a score
A share of the length, not a distance; a fulcrum whose top narrows to a point; and objects whose weight moves further from their middle as a run goes on.
A pivot is marked by how far it is from the balance point as a share of the object's length: within 1% is a perfect 100, and 20% or more is nothing, with a curve between that keeps a near miss worth having. You see it happen: the fulcrum's top narrows from 40% of the length to a point 2% wide, so the object holds within 1%, stays up nearly to the end when it is just past, and tips at once when it is far off. Each round's score is then multiplied by its place in the run, ×1, ×1, ×2, ×3 and ×3, for a perfect run of 1,000. The later rounds favor objects whose weight sits far from the middle of their outline.
Nothing is timed, nothing is dealt twice in a row, and there is no daily limit: a new run of 5 rounds is one press away.
Vocabulary
Balance and physics terms, defined
The words for where things balance, and for how they tip and fall.
- Center of mass
- The average position of all of an object's mass, weighted by how much is where. An object moves as if all its mass were there.
- Center of gravity
- The point where gravity's pull on an object can be taken to act. In a uniform field, such as near the ground, it is the same point as the center of mass.
- Balance point
- Where a long object rests level on a narrow support: the point straight under its center of mass. In Tipping Point, the point you are looking for.
- Fulcrum
- The fixed point a lever or a balance turns on. The game's fulcrum has a flat top that narrows to a point 2% of the object's length wide.
- Pivot
- Where the fulcrum holds the object in a round of Tipping Point, measured from the object's end.
- Torque
- A force's turning effect, its size times its distance from the pivot. An object tips when its weight's torque about the fulcrum's edge is no longer balanced.
- Law of the lever
- Archimedes' rule that two weights balance when each times its distance from the fulcrum is equal, so a light weight far out balances a heavy one close in.
- Moment of inertia
- How hard an object is to turn about a point, from how far its mass lies from it. Long objects have more, and topple more slowly.