Krillion UnlimitedDeep dives
From Family Feud to Pointless: A Short History of the Survey Game Show
Family Feud paid you for guessing what 100 people said. Pointless paid you for the answer none of them gave. How the survey show began, flipped itself over and became a game you can play in a browser.
Bernice Wang · Marketing Intern · 5 min read
In this article9
A survey game show asks a panel of ordinary people a question before the cameras roll, then makes contestants guess what they said. There are two ways to score it. Family Feud, which began in 1976, pays you for naming the most popular answers. Pointless, which began in 2009, pays you for the least popular ones, ideally an answer that none of the hundred gave at all.
Almost every survey game since has taken one direction or the other. Krillion takes the Pointless direction and drops the panel altogether, grading every correct answer on how many people at large would give it. Here is how the format got there, starting before television.
Before television: psychologists count the answers
The idea that answers to an open question can be counted and ranked began in the laboratory. In 1969 the psychologists William Battig and William Montague asked hundreds of American students to list members of 56 categories, "a bird", "a fruit", "a musical instrument", and published how often each answer was given, extending an American study from 1957.
Those tables, known as category norms, are rarity charts in all but name. They show the same thing every survey show would later rely on: a few answers take most of the votes, and a long tail of correct answers is given by almost nobody. Researchers have revised and expanded the norms several times since, because the shape is so dependable and so useful for experiments on memory.
Family Feud: 100 people and the top answer
Family Feud was created by Mark Goodson and premiered in ABC's daytime schedule on 12 July 1976, with Richard Dawson as host until 1985. Two families face each other across a board of hidden answers, each the response of some share of 100 people surveyed in advance. "Survey says!" became one of television's best-known catchphrases, shouted as each answer flipped over with its count.
The show has been on and off American television ever since. Ray Combs hosted from 1988, Dawson came back for a season in the mid-1990s, and Louie Anderson, Richard Karn and John O'Hurley followed before Steve Harvey took over in 2010. Britain made its own version, Family Fortunes, which launched on ITV in January 1980 with Bob Monkhouse, who nicknamed the computerised answer board "Mr Babbage". The format has since been made in dozens of countries.
The skill Family Feud tests is empathy with the crowd. You are not asked what is true; you are asked what most people would say. The winning move is to switch off your cleverness and say the obvious thing out loud, and the show's most famous moments are contestants failing to do exactly that.
Scattergories: originality at the table
The rarest-answer idea reached living rooms before it reached television. In the party game Scattergories, published in 1988, players write an answer for each category starting with a given letter, and an answer someone else also wrote scores nothing. There is no survey: the other players are the crowd, and the point of the game is to match nobody.
Pointless: the survey turned upside down
In 2009 a team at Endemol UK turned the board over. Pointless first went out on BBC Two on 24 August 2009, with Alexander Armstrong as host, and moved to BBC One in 2011. Richard Osman, one of the producers who devised it, was never meant to be on screen: he stood in as co-presenter for a run-through, and the BBC asked him to stay. He sat beside Armstrong until 2022, after which the show turned to guest co-hosts.
The survey changed too. Instead of one answer each, 100 people are given 100 seconds to name as many correct answers to a question as they can. A contestant's correct answer scores the number of people who gave it, so lower is better, and an answer nobody gave scores nothing at all: pointless, the best result the show offers. A wrong answer scores the maximum, 100.
That 100-second rule matters more than it looks. A Family Feud survey captures each person's first thought. A Pointless survey captures everything people can recall under pressure, so an answer scores low only if it is genuinely obscure, not merely somebody's second choice. Pointless rewards knowing the long tail of a category: the small country's capital, the forgotten album track, the minor river.
Pointless around the world
Pointless travelled almost as well as Family Feud. France's version, Personne n'y avait pensé!, "Nobody had thought of it", ran on France 3 with Cyril Féraud from 2011. Australia made its own Pointless for Network Ten in 2018. Several other countries have made versions of their own, and the French title sums up all of them: the answer no one else thought of.
Family Feud vs Pointless: which is harder?
They are hard in opposite ways. Family Feud punishes overthinking: the contestant who reaches for a witty or specific answer misses the board, while the one who blurts the first word wins. Pointless punishes underthinking: the first word that came to you came to dozens of the hundred as well, and the low scores live several steps further into the category.
The economist John Maynard Keynes described the Feud's problem in 1936, comparing the stock market to a newspaper beauty contest in which the winning move is to guess what average opinion expects average opinion to be. Pointless is that contest in reverse. You are trying not to meet the crowd, and the crowd's second thoughts fill up almost as fast as its first.
From a hundred people to everyone
Television has to survey a hundred people once per question and fix the result, which leaves room for only one target: the top answer, or a zero. A browser game can score every answer on a scale instead, and that is what the survey game became online.
In Krillion, each prompt has its own bank of accepted answers, and each answer sits on one of six rungs: Plankton for the answers nearly everyone gives (10 points), then Too Clever, Schooler, Rare and Deep Cut, up to One in a Krillion (100 points). An answer the bank has not seen is judged when it is first given, and the verdict is saved so the next person to give it gets the same score. A Classic dive is seven prompts with 25 seconds each, and every point sinks your krill 10 metres. Unlike Pointless, a wrong answer costs nothing but time: it is refused, and you type again while the clock runs.
The browser brings back the studio's best moment, too. In Krillion's rooms, everyone gets the same prompt on a shared clock, and when it runs out the reveal shows every player's answer and its rung, a little like watching the Pointless column count down. Our guide to a rarest answer game night shows how to run one for friends.
The Family Feud direction has its browser game as well. The Daily Games team also makes Noillirk, Krillion turned upside down: the more common your answer, the higher your krill climbs. Our comparison sets the two games side by side.
Play along for once
Neither show lets you play along beyond shouting at the screen. Krillion does: it is free, runs in your browser and has no daily limit, so you can chase your own pointless answers for as many dives as you like, alone or in a room with friends.