NoillirkComparisons

Krillion vs Noillirk: The Same Question, Scored Both Ways

One game pays you for the answer nobody gives. The other pays you for the answer everybody gives. How Krillion Unlimited and Noillirk mirror each other, where they differ, and which to play when.

Timmothy Calamansi · Student · 6 min read

In this article9

Krillion and Noillirk ask the same kind of question and score it in opposite directions. In Krillion Unlimited you win by giving the correct answer the fewest people give, and your krill sinks deeper into the ocean with every rare pick. In Noillirk you win by giving the answer the most people give, the survey's number one, and your krill rises under a bunch of balloons toward space. The name is the joke: Noillirk is Krillion spelled backwards.

Both are free, both run in the browser with no sign-up, and both are made by the Daily Games team on the same site. If you like one, the other feels familiar for about ten seconds and then strange in a good way, because the instinct that wins a prompt in one loses it in the other.

The mirror: rare scores in one, common in the other

Take a prompt like Name something you take to the beach. In Krillion, towel and sunscreen are the bottom of the barrel: everyone says them, so they score the minimum. You want something true but unexpected, a windbreak, a kite, a cool box. In Noillirk the towel may well be the top answer on the survey board, and the windbreak barely gets you off the ground.

Neither game accepts nonsense. Each judges every answer before scoring it, a wrong or made-up one is refused, and you can type again while the clock runs. Small typos and plurals pass in both. What changes is only the direction of the reward, and that turns out to change everything about how you think.

Two worlds: down to the trench, up past the universe

The score in both games is a distance, and in both every point is ten metres.

Krillion Unlimited dives. A perfect Classic dive of 700 points reaches 7,000 m, the floor of a trench, and the ocean along the way is a real one, with facts at real depths: the Titanic rests at 3,800 m, Challenger Deep bottoms out at 10,935 m. Endless keeps going past the real ocean into invented depths, down to 250 km.

Noillirk climbs. Your krill starts at a pond on the forest floor and rises through the trees and the clouds, past Everest and the airliners, over the Kármán line into orbit, out past the Moon and the planets, and on through the nearest stars, the nebulae and Andromeda to the oldest light there is. Because each stretch of climb stands for more and more real altitude, a perfect Classic climb of 700 points is 14 km up, and Endless can carry you to a googol light years. The time of day follows your height: morning in the forest, sunset where the airliners fly, night in the upper air and sunrise again at the height of the space station.

The same clock and shape

A Classic game in either is seven prompts. Each starts with a three-second count-in to read the question, then a 25-second clock. Neither pays anything for speed, and in both your first accepted answer ends the prompt. Noillirk's clock was shorter when it launched; it now matches Krillion's, which turned out to suit it, because the hard part of Noillirk is not finding an answer but choosing between several.

That is the real difference in how the clock feels. Finding a rare answer is a search: the first answers your memory hands you are the common ones, the same ones it hands everybody, so a good Krillion prompt spends its time walking past them into territory the crowd never reaches. Finding the number one answer is not a search at all. It usually comes to mind in a second or two, for you and for everyone else, alongside two or three rivals. Noillirk's 25 seconds are for judgement: deciding which of the obvious answers the crowd puts first.

The tier ladders side by side

Both games have six tiers and a miss. Here they are from the lowest-scoring to the highest.

  • Plankton, 10 points, in Krillion is the crowd favourite. Grounded, 4, in Noillirk is the answer nobody else gave.
  • Too Clever, 15, is the clever pick others also thought of. Treetop, 8, is an answer hardly anyone gave.
  • Schooler, 30, is known but not the first thing said. Kite, 16, is off the survey board but a few people said it.
  • Rare, 60, is something few would reach for. Cloud Nine, 32, is on the board, places five to nine.
  • Deep Cut, 85, is true obscurity. Jet Stream, 64, is places two to four.
  • One in a Krillion, 100, is the answer almost nobody else gave. Sky High, 100, is the board's number one.

A miss is No Catch in one and No Lift in the other, and it scores nothing in both.

The shapes differ more than the names suggest. Krillion's ladder is gentle at the top, with Deep Cut only 15 points short of the best, and its bottom tier still pays 10. Noillirk's ladder doubles at every step from Grounded to Jet Stream, so the bottom pays only 4, and up to Jet Stream each rung is worth more than all the rungs below it put together.

One answer at the top, or many

There is an asymmetry worth knowing. In Noillirk the top is exactly one answer per prompt. The board holds nine places, the number one alone is Sky High, and an answer the board does not list can never score above Cloud Nine, however sensible it sounds. Krillion's top tier has no such cap: any correct answer rare enough is One in a Krillion, and there are many ways to be rare.

So Krillion rewards breadth, and Noillirk rewards precision. The difficulty level each game prints over its prompts says the same thing in its own terms. In Krillion it rates how hard the prompt is to answer at all. In Noillirk it rates how hard the number one is to pick.

One skill, two directions

It is tempting to think the games train opposite skills. They train the same one: a model of what the crowd will say.

To win at Krillion you need to know where the crowd goes so you can go elsewhere. To win at Noillirk you need exactly that knowledge, used straight. The player who knows that everyone says towel steers clear of it in one game and plays it with confidence in the other.

What differs is the second step. In Krillion, once you have mapped the crowd, you still need the knowledge to stand outside it: a specific species, a regional dish, a technical term. In Noillirk you need to rank the crowd's choices correctly, and that depends on who the crowd is. Survey prompts are about ordinary life, and the top answer is usually the most everyday one, not the most correct or the most interesting. Experts can do worse at Noillirk than they expect, because they know too much to think like a hundred people answering in the street. There is more on that in how to get better at Noillirk.

The pair also mirrors the history of the television survey game, which began by paying for the popular answers and later turned itself upside down to pay for the unpopular ones; we told that story in from Family Feud to Pointless.

The modes compared

  • Daily: Noillirk has one, the same seven prompts for everyone, once a day. Krillion Unlimited has no daily and no limit: play as often as you like.
  • Classic: both, seven prompts, as often as you like, with no prompt coming back until you have played the whole bank.
  • Endless: both. Krillion's runs on three tanks of air, Noillirk's on three balloons. In both a miss costs one, any accepted answer keeps you going however low it scores, and the top tier wins one back.
  • Live rooms: both, up to 40 players on the same prompt at once, with private rooms on a six-digit code and a Pass key beside the answer key.
  • 1 vs 1: Krillion only. You and one opponent near your rating answer the same seven prompts, 15 seconds each, for a rating that resets each four-month season.
  • Shop: both, with separate currencies: depth tokens for metres dived, feathers for metres climbed.

Which to play when

  • Play Krillion when you have time and want to feel clever. A prompt rewards recall and specialist knowledge, and the reveal of what everyone else said is often the funniest part.
  • Play Noillirk when you want something social. Arguing over what most people would say is the classic family game-night argument, so it suits a group round one screen, and its daily gives everyone the same seven prompts to compare.
  • Play both back to back. A Noillirk climb sharpens your sense of the obvious answer, and that is exactly the answer you need to steer away from in Krillion.

Start with seven prompts in Krillion Unlimited and note which of your answers it called Plankton. Then switch to Noillirk and see how many of those same instincts take you straight to Sky High. One game tells you how well you avoid the crowd; the other tells you how well you know it.

All stories